If you're an English-speaking expat starting a business in Spain, you will need to take some important decisions.
Most expat entrepreneurs begin with businesses they understand well - cafes and restaurants, property management, tourism services, or English language teaching. Digital businesses are increasingly popular too, with many choosing to run online services or consulting firms while enjoying Spain's quality of life. But setting up a business in a new country brings extra challenges compared to a country you've been familiar with all your life.
You'll need to deal with Spanish bureaucracy, which can be time-consuming and complex if you're not fluent in the language. Understanding local business practices, tax requirements, and regulatory compliance takes time and most expats need professional help, at the very least, to get started.
Many expats find that seemingly simple tasks, like opening a bank account or registering with the tax office, can become complicated due to language barriers and unfamiliar procedures.
Before you tackle any of these challenges, though, you need to make a crucial decision that will affect your business for years to come: should you set up a limited liability company LLC or register as a sole trader?
This choice will impact your tax obligations, personal liability, and ongoing administrative costs. Making the right decision early can save you significant money and stress down the line, while, on the other hand, choosing incorrectly might mean costly restructuring later. Don't let your burning desire to get your business going overcome the need to stand back and make a calm and well-thought through choice.
Let's examine both options in detail so you can make an informed choice for your Spanish business venture.
Want to hear what other clients
are saying about us?
1. Which is Better: LLC or Sole Trader in Spain?
Starting a business in Spain requires an immediate, but critical decision: should you establish a limited liability company LLC (S.L.) or register as a sole trader (autónomo)? Your choice can significantly impact your finances and future business operations.
2. Initial Setup and Capital Requirements
A limited liability company LLC in Spain requires:
- €3,000 minimum share capital
- A tax identification number
- Registration in the commercial registry
- A corporate bank account
- A distinct company name
In contrast, a sole proprietorship doesn't demand initial share capital, making it an attractive option for entrepreneurs just starting their business activities with limited funds.
3. Fiscal Obligations: A Key Difference
Both business structures must handle VAT (IVA) and income tax returns, but their tax obligations differ significantly:
For a limited liability company LLC:
- Corporate tax returns (impuesto de sociedades)
- Annual accounts filing with the commercial registry
- Must withhold 15% from invoices from professionals/autonomos
- Higher maintenance costs due to additional reporting (approx €250 p/m accounting costs for small businesses)
For a sole trader:
- Simpler tax reporting structure
- Lower administrative burden
- More straightforward accounting requirements (typically around €65 p/m per sole-trader)
- Direct income tax liability (annual income tax return)
4. Social Security Commitments
The social security obligations will vary between the structures:
Sole Trader:
- Mandatory monthly contributions (start at €80 p/m rising to minimum €250 after 2 years, according to income)
- Payments required regardless of income
- Special reductions available for under-30s
- Temporary discounts for formerly unemployed individuals
Limited liability company LLC:
- 24% social security contributions for employees
- Directors must register as autonomos if no other employees
- Additional bank account management requirements
- More complex share capital considerations
Want to hear what other clients
are saying about us?
5. Understanding Liability Protection
A Spanish limited liability company provides crucial protection:
- Company's debts limited to business assets
- Personal assets generally protected
- Minimum share capital serves as creditor protection
- Legal entity status separates business and personal finances
For sole proprietorship:
- Full personal liability for business debts
- No separation between personal and business assets
- Higher personal risk in case of business troubles
- Personal responsibility for tax and social security obligations
6. Cost Considerations
The financial implications vary significantly:
Limited liability company LLC costs:
- Initial share capital requirement
- Higher administrative expenses
- Additional corporate tax rate obligations
- More complex accounting needs
Sole trader expenses:
- Lower startup costs
- Reduced administrative burden
- Simplified tax structure
- Higher personal social security contributions
7. Making Your Decision
Consider the below factors when choosing your business structure:
For stable, growing operations:
- An LLC in Spain offers better protection
- Supports multiple shareholders
- More credible for commercial activities
- Better suited for foreign investors
For smaller ventures:
- Sole proprietorship provides flexibility
- Faster setup process
- Lower initial costs
- Simpler management structure
8. Summary: Making Your Choice
Your decision between an LLC in Spain and sole trader status isn't just about paperwork - it's about protecting your future and setting up your business for success. To recap the key points:
Choose a limited liability company LLC if:
- You expect significant income or rapid growth
- You have €3,000 for initial share capital
- You want to protect your personal assets
- You're planning to hire employees
- You can handle more complex administrative tasks
- You need a more professional image for clients
Go with sole trader (autónomo) status if:
- You're just starting out or testing the waters
- Your expected income is moderate
- You want lower startup and running costs
- You prefer simpler accounting and tax filing
- You're operating alone or as a freelancer
- You can manage the higher social security payments
Remember: as an English-speaking expat, either choice will require dealing with Spanish bureaucracy and possibly hiring professional help, at least initially.
Start by assessing your business plan, available capital, and long-term goals. Then speak with a qualified advisor who understands both Spanish business law and expat needs - they can help you match your specific situation to the right business structure.
The good news? Both options are completely viable for foreign entrepreneurs in Spain. Your success will depend more on your business execution than your legal structure - but choosing the right one from the start will make that execution much smoother!
